Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia

Recent studies have shown that Acacia is polyphyletic and must be split into five genera. Proposal 1584 would retypify Acacia: the type of the Australian taxon A. penninervis would be conserved over the current lectotype (A. scorpioides) of an African taxon. We disagree with the recommendation of th...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Luckow, M., Hughes, C., Schrire, B., Winter, P., Fagg, C., Fortunato, R., Hurter, J., Rico, L., Breteler, F.J., Bruneau, A., Caccavari, M., Craven, L., Crisp, M., Alfonso Delgado, S., Demissew, S., Doyle, J.J., Grether, R., Harris, S., Herendeen, P.S., Hernández, H.M., Hirsch, A.M., Jobson, R., Klitgaard, B.B., Labat, J.-N., Lock, M., MacKinder, B., Pfeil, B., Simpson, B.B., Smith, G.F., Sousa S., M., Timberlake, J., Van Der Maesen, J.G., Van Wyk, A.E., Vorster, P., Willis, C.K., Wieringa, J.J., Wojciechowski, M.F.
Formato: JOUR
Materias:
Acacia
Conservation
Leguminosae
Nomenclature
Retypification
taxonomy
Fabaceae
Acceso en línea:http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12110/paper_00400262_v54_n2_p513_Luckow
Aporte de:
Biblioteca Digital - Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales (UBA) de Universidad de Buenos Aires
id todo:paper_00400262_v54_n2_p513_Luckow
record_format dspace
spelling todo:paper_00400262_v54_n2_p513_Luckow2023-10-03T14:50:03Z Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia Luckow, M. Hughes, C. Schrire, B. Winter, P. Fagg, C. Fortunato, R. Hurter, J. Rico, L. Breteler, F.J. Bruneau, A. Caccavari, M. Craven, L. Crisp, M. Alfonso Delgado, S. Demissew, S. Doyle, J.J. Grether, R. Harris, S. Herendeen, P.S. Hernández, H.M. Hirsch, A.M. Jobson, R. Klitgaard, B.B. Labat, J.-N. Lock, M. MacKinder, B. Pfeil, B. Simpson, B.B. Smith, G.F. Sousa S., M. Timberlake, J. Van Der Maesen, J.G. Van Wyk, A.E. Vorster, P. Willis, C.K. Wieringa, J.J. Wojciechowski, M.F. Acacia Conservation Leguminosae Nomenclature Retypification taxonomy Acacia Fabaceae Recent studies have shown that Acacia is polyphyletic and must be split into five genera. Proposal 1584 would retypify Acacia: the type of the Australian taxon A. penninervis would be conserved over the current lectotype (A. scorpioides) of an African taxon. We disagree with the recommendation of the Spermatophyte Committee to endorse this proposal. Contrary to Article 14.12 of the ICBN, no detailed case against conservation was presented in Proposal 1584. We maintain that there are strong arguments against conservation, such as the large number of countries that would be affected, the economic importance of the extra-Australian species, and the economic burden placed on developing countries. Acceptance of this proposal would also violate the guidelines for conservation which clearly state that the principle of priority should prevail when conservation for one part of the world would create disadvantageous change in another part of the world. JOUR info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ar http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12110/paper_00400262_v54_n2_p513_Luckow
institution Universidad de Buenos Aires
institution_str I-28
repository_str R-134
collection Biblioteca Digital - Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales (UBA)
topic Acacia
Conservation
Leguminosae
Nomenclature
Retypification
taxonomy
Acacia
Fabaceae
spellingShingle Acacia
Conservation
Leguminosae
Nomenclature
Retypification
taxonomy
Acacia
Fabaceae
Luckow, M.
Hughes, C.
Schrire, B.
Winter, P.
Fagg, C.
Fortunato, R.
Hurter, J.
Rico, L.
Breteler, F.J.
Bruneau, A.
Caccavari, M.
Craven, L.
Crisp, M.
Alfonso Delgado, S.
Demissew, S.
Doyle, J.J.
Grether, R.
Harris, S.
Herendeen, P.S.
Hernández, H.M.
Hirsch, A.M.
Jobson, R.
Klitgaard, B.B.
Labat, J.-N.
Lock, M.
MacKinder, B.
Pfeil, B.
Simpson, B.B.
Smith, G.F.
Sousa S., M.
Timberlake, J.
Van Der Maesen, J.G.
Van Wyk, A.E.
Vorster, P.
Willis, C.K.
Wieringa, J.J.
Wojciechowski, M.F.
Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
topic_facet Acacia
Conservation
Leguminosae
Nomenclature
Retypification
taxonomy
Acacia
Fabaceae
description Recent studies have shown that Acacia is polyphyletic and must be split into five genera. Proposal 1584 would retypify Acacia: the type of the Australian taxon A. penninervis would be conserved over the current lectotype (A. scorpioides) of an African taxon. We disagree with the recommendation of the Spermatophyte Committee to endorse this proposal. Contrary to Article 14.12 of the ICBN, no detailed case against conservation was presented in Proposal 1584. We maintain that there are strong arguments against conservation, such as the large number of countries that would be affected, the economic importance of the extra-Australian species, and the economic burden placed on developing countries. Acceptance of this proposal would also violate the guidelines for conservation which clearly state that the principle of priority should prevail when conservation for one part of the world would create disadvantageous change in another part of the world.
format JOUR
author Luckow, M.
Hughes, C.
Schrire, B.
Winter, P.
Fagg, C.
Fortunato, R.
Hurter, J.
Rico, L.
Breteler, F.J.
Bruneau, A.
Caccavari, M.
Craven, L.
Crisp, M.
Alfonso Delgado, S.
Demissew, S.
Doyle, J.J.
Grether, R.
Harris, S.
Herendeen, P.S.
Hernández, H.M.
Hirsch, A.M.
Jobson, R.
Klitgaard, B.B.
Labat, J.-N.
Lock, M.
MacKinder, B.
Pfeil, B.
Simpson, B.B.
Smith, G.F.
Sousa S., M.
Timberlake, J.
Van Der Maesen, J.G.
Van Wyk, A.E.
Vorster, P.
Willis, C.K.
Wieringa, J.J.
Wojciechowski, M.F.
author_facet Luckow, M.
Hughes, C.
Schrire, B.
Winter, P.
Fagg, C.
Fortunato, R.
Hurter, J.
Rico, L.
Breteler, F.J.
Bruneau, A.
Caccavari, M.
Craven, L.
Crisp, M.
Alfonso Delgado, S.
Demissew, S.
Doyle, J.J.
Grether, R.
Harris, S.
Herendeen, P.S.
Hernández, H.M.
Hirsch, A.M.
Jobson, R.
Klitgaard, B.B.
Labat, J.-N.
Lock, M.
MacKinder, B.
Pfeil, B.
Simpson, B.B.
Smith, G.F.
Sousa S., M.
Timberlake, J.
Van Der Maesen, J.G.
Van Wyk, A.E.
Vorster, P.
Willis, C.K.
Wieringa, J.J.
Wojciechowski, M.F.
author_sort Luckow, M.
title Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
title_short Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
title_full Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
title_fullStr Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
title_full_unstemmed Acacia: The case against moving the type to Australia
title_sort acacia: the case against moving the type to australia
url http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12110/paper_00400262_v54_n2_p513_Luckow
work_keys_str_mv AT luckowm acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT hughesc acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT schrireb acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT winterp acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT faggc acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT fortunator acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT hurterj acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT ricol acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT bretelerfj acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT bruneaua acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT caccavarim acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT cravenl acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT crispm acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT alfonsodelgados acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT demissews acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT doylejj acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT gretherr acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT harriss acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT herendeenps acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT hernandezhm acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT hirscham acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT jobsonr acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT klitgaardbb acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT labatjn acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT lockm acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT mackinderb acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT pfeilb acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT simpsonbb acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT smithgf acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT sousasm acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT timberlakej acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT vandermaesenjg acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT vanwykae acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT vorsterp acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT willisck acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT wieringajj acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
AT wojciechowskimf acaciathecaseagainstmovingthetypetoaustralia
_version_ 1807320452317577216

Ejemplares similares