Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina

The following is an unpublished text written by Jorge Schvarzer in July 2001. Shortly before, a rich polemic had taken place between this author and Roy Hora on the characteristics of landowners and industrial entrepreneurs in agro-exporting Argentina in the pages of the journal Desarrollo Económico...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Schvarzer, Jorge
Formato: Artículo publishedVersion
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: Centro de Estudios de Historia Económica Argentina y Latinoamericana (CEHEAL) 2013
Materias:
Debate
Class Conflict
Ruling Class
Conflicto de Clase
Clase Dominante
Acceso en línea:https://ojs.economicas.uba.ar/H-ind/article/view/382
https://repositoriouba.sisbi.uba.ar/gsdl/cgi-bin/library.cgi?a=d&c=hindus&d=382_oai
Aporte de:
Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Buenos Aires (UBA) de Universidad de Buenos Aires
id I28-R145-382_oai
record_format dspace
spelling I28-R145-382_oai2026-02-09 Schvarzer, Jorge 2013-01-10 The following is an unpublished text written by Jorge Schvarzer in July 2001. Shortly before, a rich polemic had taken place between this author and Roy Hora on the characteristics of landowners and industrial entrepreneurs in agro-exporting Argentina in the pages of the journal Desarrollo Económico; this debate was initially precipitated by the publication of Hora's article "Landlords, industrial entrepreneurs and industrial growth in Argentina and the debate on protectionism (1890-1914)" (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 40, no. 159, October-December 2000). Schvarzer commented on the work in "Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en el ya antiguo debate sobre el desarrollo argentino" (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 41, no. 161, April-June 2001) and Hora responded to that comment in "Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en la Argentina: respuesta a una crítica" in the same issue of the journal. The text published here was written by a vehement Schvarzer, as soon as the ink of Hora's reply was dry, with the purpose of continuing that debate; however, he later discarded the idea and left it unfinished. His argument was that the "counter-response" would necessarily have to be very long, a format not suitable for publication in the "Notes and Comments" section of Desarrollo Económico, where the exchange had been taking place until then. Presentamos a continuación un texto inédito elaborado por Jorge Schvarzer en julio de 2001. Poco antes había tenido lugar una rica polémica entre este autor y Roy Hora sobre las características de los empresarios terratenientes e industriales en la Argentina agroexportadora en las páginas de la revista Desarrollo Económico; ese debate se precipitó inicialmente por la publicación del artículo de Hora “Terra- tenientes, empresarios industriales y crecimiento industrial en la Argentina y el debate sobre el protec- cionismo (1890-1914)” (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 40, nro. 159, octubre-diciembre de 2000). Schvarzer comentó el trabajo en “Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en el ya antiguo debate sobre el desarrollo argentino” (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 41, nro. 161, abril-junio de 2001) y Hora respondió a ese comentario a través de “Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en la Argentina: respuesta a una crítica” en el mismo número de la revista. El texto que se publica fue escrito por un vehemente Schvarzer, apenas secada la tinta de la res- puesta de Hora, con el propósito de continuar ese debate; no obstante, posteriormente descartó la idea y lo dejó inconcluso. Su argumento fue que la “contra-respuesta” debía necesariamente ser muy extensa, un formato no apto para ser publicado en la sección “Notas y comentarios” de Desarrollo Económico, donde hasta entonces se había desplegado el intercambio. application/pdf https://ojs.economicas.uba.ar/H-ind/article/view/382 spa Centro de Estudios de Historia Económica Argentina y Latinoamericana (CEHEAL) https://ojs.economicas.uba.ar/H-ind/article/view/382/696 H-industria. Journal of the History of Industry and Development in Latin America; No. 10 (6): Primer semestre de 2012; 1 H-industria. Revista de historia de la industria y el desarrollo en América Latina; Núm. 10 (6): Primer semestre de 2012; 1 H-industria. Revista sobre a história da indústria e desenvolvimento na América Latina; n. 10 (6): Primer semestre de 2012; 1 1851-703X Debate Class Conflict Ruling Class Debate Conflicto de Clase Clase Dominante Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina Clases en conflicto y conflicto de ideas sobre las clases: Una aclaración necesaria para la polémica sobre la clase dominante en la Argentina moderna info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion https://repositoriouba.sisbi.uba.ar/gsdl/cgi-bin/library.cgi?a=d&c=hindus&d=382_oai
institution Universidad de Buenos Aires
institution_str I-28
repository_str R-145
collection Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Buenos Aires (UBA)
language Español
orig_language_str_mv spa
topic Debate
Class Conflict
Ruling Class
Debate
Conflicto de Clase
Clase Dominante
spellingShingle Debate
Class Conflict
Ruling Class
Debate
Conflicto de Clase
Clase Dominante
Schvarzer, Jorge
Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
topic_facet Debate
Class Conflict
Ruling Class
Debate
Conflicto de Clase
Clase Dominante
description The following is an unpublished text written by Jorge Schvarzer in July 2001. Shortly before, a rich polemic had taken place between this author and Roy Hora on the characteristics of landowners and industrial entrepreneurs in agro-exporting Argentina in the pages of the journal Desarrollo Económico; this debate was initially precipitated by the publication of Hora's article "Landlords, industrial entrepreneurs and industrial growth in Argentina and the debate on protectionism (1890-1914)" (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 40, no. 159, October-December 2000). Schvarzer commented on the work in "Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en el ya antiguo debate sobre el desarrollo argentino" (Desarrollo Económico, vol. 41, no. 161, April-June 2001) and Hora responded to that comment in "Terratenientes, industriales y clase dominante en la Argentina: respuesta a una crítica" in the same issue of the journal. The text published here was written by a vehement Schvarzer, as soon as the ink of Hora's reply was dry, with the purpose of continuing that debate; however, he later discarded the idea and left it unfinished. His argument was that the "counter-response" would necessarily have to be very long, a format not suitable for publication in the "Notes and Comments" section of Desarrollo Económico, where the exchange had been taking place until then.
format Artículo
publishedVersion
author Schvarzer, Jorge
author_facet Schvarzer, Jorge
author_sort Schvarzer, Jorge
title Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
title_short Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
title_full Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
title_fullStr Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
title_full_unstemmed Classes in Conflict and Conflict of Ideas About Classes: A Necessary Clarification for the Polemic on the Ruling Class in Modern Argentina
title_sort classes in conflict and conflict of ideas about classes: a necessary clarification for the polemic on the ruling class in modern argentina
publisher Centro de Estudios de Historia Económica Argentina y Latinoamericana (CEHEAL)
publishDate 2013
url https://ojs.economicas.uba.ar/H-ind/article/view/382
https://repositoriouba.sisbi.uba.ar/gsdl/cgi-bin/library.cgi?a=d&c=hindus&d=382_oai
work_keys_str_mv AT schvarzerjorge classesinconflictandconflictofideasaboutclassesanecessaryclarificationforthepolemicontherulingclassinmodernargentina
AT schvarzerjorge clasesenconflictoyconflictodeideassobrelasclasesunaaclaracionnecesariaparalapolemicasobrelaclasedominanteenlaargentinamoderna
_version_ 1857041361854791680

Ejemplares similares