Psicologismo y normatividad lógica

This paper examines the relationship between psychologism and the normative status of logic. Traditionally, the thesis of the normativity of logic has been used to argue against psychologism. However, contemporary anti-psychologistic positions lead to a purely descriptive characterization of logic t...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Massolo, Alba
Formato: Artículo revista
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: ARFIL y UNL 2025
Materias:
Logic and Reasoning
Psychologism
Antipsychologism
Normativity
Naturalism
Lógica y Razonamiento
Psicologismo
Antipsicologismo
Normatividad
Naturalismo
Acceso en línea:https://bibliotecavirtual.unl.edu.ar/publicaciones/index.php/index/article/view/14213
Aporte de:
Biblioteca Virtual - Publicaciones (UNL) de Universidad Nacional del Litoral
id I26-R133-article-14213
record_format ojs
spelling I26-R133-article-142132025-12-05T12:00:21Z Psicologismo y normatividad lógica Massolo, Alba Logic and Reasoning Psychologism Antipsychologism Normativity Naturalism Lógica y Razonamiento Psicologismo Antipsicologismo Normatividad Naturalismo This paper examines the relationship between psychologism and the normative status of logic. Traditionally, the thesis of the normativity of logic has been used to argue against psychologism. However, contemporary anti-psychologistic positions lead to a purely descriptive characterization of logic that distances it from its purportedly intrinsic normative function. Against this trend, I argue that the defence of logical normativity requires a position akin to psychologism. On the one hand, I show that anti-psychologistic positions cannot adequately account for the connection between logic and reasoning. On the other hand, I argue that a current variant of psychologism, called social psychologism, can account for the connection between logic and the cognitive processes involved in human reasoning and thus vindicate the thesis of logical normativity. My argument considers why this variant of psychologism is preferable to other current proposals offered in this discussion, such as Robert Hanna's (2006) cognitivism. Este artículo examina la relación entre el psicologismo y el carácter normativo de la lógica. Tradicionalmente, la tesis de la normatividad lógica fue utilizada para argumentar en contra del psicologismo. Sin embargo, en la actualidad, las posturas antipsicologistas derivan en una caracterización puramente descriptiva de la lógica que la aleja de su pretendida función intrínsecamente normativa. En contra de esta tendencia, sostengo que la defensa de la normatividad lógica requiere sustentarse en una postura afín al psicologismo. Por un lado, muestro que las posturas antipsicologistas no pueden dar cuenta de manera adecuada del vínculo de la lógica con el razonamiento. Y, por otro lado, argumento cómo una variante actual de psicologismo, denominada psicologismo social, permite dar cuenta de la conexión entre la lógica y los procesos cognitivos vinculados al razonamiento humano, y, de esta manera, justificar la tesis de la normatividad lógica. Mi argumento contempla por qué esta variante de psicologismo es preferible a otras propuestas actuales que se han ofrecido en el marco de esta discusión, como es el caso de la postura cognitivista de Robert Hanna (2006). ARFIL y UNL 2025-12-05 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://bibliotecavirtual.unl.edu.ar/publicaciones/index.php/index/article/view/14213 10.14409/topicos.2025.47.e0133 Tópicos. Revista de Filosofía de Santa Fe; No. 47 (2025): Tópicos. Revista de Filosofía de Santa Fe; e0133 Tópicos. Revista de Filosofía de Santa Fe; Núm. 47 (2025): Tópicos. Revista de Filosofía de Santa Fe; e0133 1668-723X 1666-485X 10.14409/topicos.2025.47 es https://bibliotecavirtual.unl.edu.ar/publicaciones/index.php/index/article/view/14213/20743 Derechos de autor 1969 Alba Massolo https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
institution Universidad Nacional del Litoral
institution_str I-26
repository_str R-133
container_title_str Biblioteca Virtual - Publicaciones (UNL)
language Español
format Artículo revista
topic Logic and Reasoning
Psychologism
Antipsychologism
Normativity
Naturalism
Lógica y Razonamiento
Psicologismo
Antipsicologismo
Normatividad
Naturalismo
spellingShingle Logic and Reasoning
Psychologism
Antipsychologism
Normativity
Naturalism
Lógica y Razonamiento
Psicologismo
Antipsicologismo
Normatividad
Naturalismo
Massolo, Alba
Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
topic_facet Logic and Reasoning
Psychologism
Antipsychologism
Normativity
Naturalism
Lógica y Razonamiento
Psicologismo
Antipsicologismo
Normatividad
Naturalismo
author Massolo, Alba
author_facet Massolo, Alba
author_sort Massolo, Alba
title Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
title_short Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
title_full Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
title_fullStr Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
title_full_unstemmed Psicologismo y normatividad lógica
title_sort psicologismo y normatividad lógica
description This paper examines the relationship between psychologism and the normative status of logic. Traditionally, the thesis of the normativity of logic has been used to argue against psychologism. However, contemporary anti-psychologistic positions lead to a purely descriptive characterization of logic that distances it from its purportedly intrinsic normative function. Against this trend, I argue that the defence of logical normativity requires a position akin to psychologism. On the one hand, I show that anti-psychologistic positions cannot adequately account for the connection between logic and reasoning. On the other hand, I argue that a current variant of psychologism, called social psychologism, can account for the connection between logic and the cognitive processes involved in human reasoning and thus vindicate the thesis of logical normativity. My argument considers why this variant of psychologism is preferable to other current proposals offered in this discussion, such as Robert Hanna's (2006) cognitivism.
publisher ARFIL y UNL
publishDate 2025
url https://bibliotecavirtual.unl.edu.ar/publicaciones/index.php/index/article/view/14213
work_keys_str_mv AT massoloalba psicologismoynormatividadlogica
first_indexed 2025-12-15T05:06:32Z
last_indexed 2025-12-15T05:06:32Z
_version_ 1851549488635707392

Ejemplares similares