Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators
Collaboration between industry and university has been postulated as the panacea for regional development. Both academics and politicians have devoted countless resources to justify and demonstrate the need for this intersectoral work. However, the evidence in Argentine still shows an industry that...
Guardado en:
| Autor principal: | |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Artículo revista |
| Lenguaje: | Español |
| Publicado: |
Núcleo de Estudios e Investigaciones en Educación Superior del MERCOSUR
2022
|
| Materias: | |
| Acceso en línea: | https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/integracionyconocimiento/article/view/38431 |
| Aporte de: |
| id |
I10-R376-article-38431 |
|---|---|
| record_format |
ojs |
| institution |
Universidad Nacional de Córdoba |
| institution_str |
I-10 |
| repository_str |
R-376 |
| container_title_str |
Integración y Conocimiento |
| language |
Español |
| format |
Artículo revista |
| topic |
academy-industry collaboration, university third mission, intermediary organizations, business incubators colaboración academia-industria, tercera misión universitaria, organizaciones intermediarias, incubadoras de empresas. colaboração academia-indústria, terceira missão universitária, organizações intermediárias, incubadoras de empresas. |
| spellingShingle |
academy-industry collaboration, university third mission, intermediary organizations, business incubators colaboración academia-industria, tercera misión universitaria, organizaciones intermediarias, incubadoras de empresas. colaboração academia-indústria, terceira missão universitária, organizações intermediárias, incubadoras de empresas. Negro-Hang, Frida Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| topic_facet |
academy-industry collaboration, university third mission, intermediary organizations, business incubators colaboración academia-industria, tercera misión universitaria, organizaciones intermediarias, incubadoras de empresas. colaboração academia-indústria, terceira missão universitária, organizações intermediárias, incubadoras de empresas. |
| author |
Negro-Hang, Frida |
| author_facet |
Negro-Hang, Frida |
| author_sort |
Negro-Hang, Frida |
| title |
Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| title_short |
Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| title_full |
Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| title_fullStr |
Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| title_sort |
three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators |
| description |
Collaboration between industry and university has been postulated as the panacea for regional development. Both academics and politicians have devoted countless resources to justify and demonstrate the need for this intersectoral work. However, the evidence in Argentine still shows an industry that does not identify when links with university are possible, and also, a university that does not find relevant and sustainable mechanisms to share its capital with other sectors of the economy. This paper argues that there are three analytical elements of linkages on which decision-makers should work in depth to increase the probability of successful collaborations. The elements considered are: a) the clear identification of objectives pursued by the initiative; b) the role attributed to the policy implementation mechanisms; c) the evaluation tools used to monitor the initiatives. To address this problem, the case of university business incubators is specifically analyzed. They are understood as a mechanism boost by universities to improve collaborations with industry. The analytical elements are applied considering argentine environment. The analyze of each element shows how a deficient implementation of the initiatives has a negative impact on the credibility and legitimacy of involved institutions |
| publisher |
Núcleo de Estudios e Investigaciones en Educación Superior del MERCOSUR |
| publishDate |
2022 |
| url |
https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/integracionyconocimiento/article/view/38431 |
| work_keys_str_mv |
AT negrohangfrida threeelementstothinkcriticallyaboutoutreachpoliciesanalyzingthecaseofuniversitybusinessincubators AT negrohangfrida treselementosparapensarcriticamentelaspoliticasdevinculacionanalizandoelcasodelasincubadorasdeempresasuniversitarias AT negrohangfrida ligandouniversidadessetoresprodutivosmudancadeeraesociedadecontemporanea |
| first_indexed |
2024-09-03T23:05:54Z |
| last_indexed |
2024-09-03T23:05:54Z |
| _version_ |
1809218015860883456 |
| spelling |
I10-R376-article-384312023-02-01T03:27:10Z Three elements to think critically about outreach policies: analyzing the case of university business incubators Tres elementos para pensar críticamente las políticas de vinculación: analizando el caso de las incubadoras de empresas universitarias Ligando Universidades-Setores Produtivos, Mudança de Era e Sociedade Contemporânea Negro-Hang, Frida academy-industry collaboration, university third mission, intermediary organizations, business incubators colaboración academia-industria, tercera misión universitaria, organizaciones intermediarias, incubadoras de empresas. colaboração academia-indústria, terceira missão universitária, organizações intermediárias, incubadoras de empresas. Collaboration between industry and university has been postulated as the panacea for regional development. Both academics and politicians have devoted countless resources to justify and demonstrate the need for this intersectoral work. However, the evidence in Argentine still shows an industry that does not identify when links with university are possible, and also, a university that does not find relevant and sustainable mechanisms to share its capital with other sectors of the economy. This paper argues that there are three analytical elements of linkages on which decision-makers should work in depth to increase the probability of successful collaborations. The elements considered are: a) the clear identification of objectives pursued by the initiative; b) the role attributed to the policy implementation mechanisms; c) the evaluation tools used to monitor the initiatives. To address this problem, the case of university business incubators is specifically analyzed. They are understood as a mechanism boost by universities to improve collaborations with industry. The analytical elements are applied considering argentine environment. The analyze of each element shows how a deficient implementation of the initiatives has a negative impact on the credibility and legitimacy of involved institutions La colaboración entre el sector productivo y la academia se postula de a momentos como la panacea del desarrollo regional. Tanto académicos como políticos han destinado incontables cantidades de recursos a justificar y demostrar la necesidad de este trabajo intersectorial. Sin embargo, en la realidad argentina aún se identifica un sector productivo que no sabe cuándo y cómo vincularse con la academia, y una universidad que no encuentra concretos y sostenibles mecanismos para acercar sus capitales a otros sectores de la economía. Este trabajo sostiene que existen tres elementos analíticos propios de la vinculación sobre los cuales los tomadores de decisiones deben trabajar con mayor profundidad para incrementar la probabilidad de éxito de las colaboraciones. Los elementos considerados son: a) la clara identificación del objetivo que persigue la iniciativa; b) el rol que se atribuye a los mecanismos de implementación de las políticas; c) las herramientas de evaluación utilizadas para dar seguimiento a las iniciativas. Para abordar esta problematización, se analiza específicamente el caso de las incubadoras de empresas universitarias, entendidas como mecanismo de vinculación entre la academia y el sector productivo. Los elementos analíticos son aplicados al caso en cuestión, poniendo particular énfasis en la realidad argentina. La reflexión sobre cada uno de ellos evidencia cómo una deficiente implementación de las iniciativas impacta negativamente sobre la credibilidad y legitimidad de las instituciones involucradas A colaboração entre o sector produtivo e a academia é as vezes postulada como a panaceia para o desenvolvimento regional. Académicos e políticos têm dedicado muitos recursos para justificar e demonstrar a necessidade deste trabalho inter-sectorial. Contudo, na realidade argentina, podemos ainda identificar um sector produtivo que não sabe quando e como se ligar ao mundo académico, e uma universidade que não encontra mecanismos concretos e sustentáveis para aproximar o seu capital de outros sectores da economia. Este documento argumenta que existem três elementos analíticos de ligação, sobre os quais os decisores precisam de trabalhar em maior profundidade, para assim aumentar a probabilidade de colaborações bem sucedidas. Os elementos considerados são: a) a identificação clara do objectivo perseguido pela iniciativa; b) o papel atribuído aos mecanismos de implementação de políticas; c) os instrumentos de avaliação utilizados para monitorizar as iniciativas. A fim de resolver este problema, é analisado especificamente o caso das incubadoras de empresas universitárias, entendidas como um mecanismo de ligação entre o meio académico e o sector produtivo. Os elementos analíticos são aplicados ao caso em questão, com particular destaque para a realidade argentina. A reflexão sobre cada uma delas mostra como uma implementação deficiente das iniciativas tem um impacto negativo na credibilidade e legitimidade das instituições envolvidas. Núcleo de Estudios e Investigaciones en Educación Superior del MERCOSUR 2022-07-31 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/integracionyconocimiento/article/view/38431 10.61203/2347-0658.v11.n2.38431 Integración y Conocimiento; Vol. 11 No. 2 (2022): Integración y Conocimiento; 45-61 Integración y Conocimiento; Vol. 11 Núm. 2 (2022): Integración y Conocimiento; 45-61 Integración y Conocimiento; v. 11 n. 2 (2022): Integración y Conocimiento; 45-61 2347-0658 10.61203/2347-0658.v11.n2 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/integracionyconocimiento/article/view/38431/38484 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0 |