Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries
Introduction: Some studies conducted in Latin America have evaluated the access and use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) by healthcare personnel in health services. However, the instruments that were used focused on specific technologies and had limited evidence regarding validity...
Guardado en:
| Autores principales: | , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Artículo revista |
| Lenguaje: | Español |
| Publicado: |
Escuela de Salud Pública y Ambiente. Fac. Cs. Médicas UNC
2023
|
| Materias: | |
| Acceso en línea: | https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/RSD/article/view/38884 |
| Aporte de: |
| id |
I10-R360-article-38884 |
|---|---|
| record_format |
ojs |
| institution |
Universidad Nacional de Córdoba |
| institution_str |
I-10 |
| repository_str |
R-360 |
| container_title_str |
Revista de Salud Pública |
| language |
Español |
| format |
Artículo revista |
| topic |
Validation Study Case Management Health Systems Delphi Technique Information Technology Estudio de validación Manejo de caso Sistemas de salud Técnica Delfos Tecnología de la información |
| spellingShingle |
Validation Study Case Management Health Systems Delphi Technique Information Technology Estudio de validación Manejo de caso Sistemas de salud Técnica Delfos Tecnología de la información Cabrera Mendoza, Néstor Iván Díaz de León Castañeda, Christian Vélez Álvarez, Consuelo Pavón León, Patricia Gogeascoechea Trejo, María del Carmen Gutiérrez Alba, Gaudencio Campos Uscanga, Yolanda Ortiz León, María Cristina Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| topic_facet |
Validation Study Case Management Health Systems Delphi Technique Information Technology Estudio de validación Manejo de caso Sistemas de salud Técnica Delfos Tecnología de la información |
| author |
Cabrera Mendoza, Néstor Iván Díaz de León Castañeda, Christian Vélez Álvarez, Consuelo Pavón León, Patricia Gogeascoechea Trejo, María del Carmen Gutiérrez Alba, Gaudencio Campos Uscanga, Yolanda Ortiz León, María Cristina |
| author_facet |
Cabrera Mendoza, Néstor Iván Díaz de León Castañeda, Christian Vélez Álvarez, Consuelo Pavón León, Patricia Gogeascoechea Trejo, María del Carmen Gutiérrez Alba, Gaudencio Campos Uscanga, Yolanda Ortiz León, María Cristina |
| author_sort |
Cabrera Mendoza, Néstor Iván |
| title |
Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| title_short |
Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| title_full |
Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| title_fullStr |
Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries |
| title_sort |
content validity of the questionnaire ‘technology acceptance in health systems’ (aceptess) in two latin american countries |
| description |
Introduction: Some studies conducted in Latin America have evaluated the access and use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) by healthcare personnel in health services. However, the instruments that were used focused on specific technologies and had limited evidence regarding validity and reliability.
Objective: To develop a questionnaire to assess the availability, acceptance, and use of ICT as mechanisms for care coordination and the factors influencing public health services, and to analyze its content validity.
Materials and Methods: The questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) was designed and adapted for Mexico and Colombia. Content validity was analyzed using Delphi method in three phases: 1) preparatory phase, 2) consultation phase, and 3) consensus phase. Nineteen judges, experts in Health Technologies and Health Systems Management participated (8 in Mexico and 11 in Colombia). A digital validation format was used to evaluate the questionnaire items based on four categories: sufficiency, clarity, coherence, and relevance. Consultation phase included two rounds; and degree of agreement among experts was determined using the content validity coefficient. Results: The ACEPTESS questionnaire obtained an overall "excellent" level of agreement in both countries (Mexico: 0.9541; Colombia: 0.9644). The final version of the ACEPTESS questionnaire included 65 items divided into four sections.
Conclusions: The results suggest that the ACEPTESS questionnaire has evidence of content validity for assessing ICT as mechanisms for care coordination and the factors influencing public health services in Mexico and Colombia.
Keywords: Validation study, Case management, Health systems, Delphi Technique, IT |
| publisher |
Escuela de Salud Pública y Ambiente. Fac. Cs. Médicas UNC |
| publishDate |
2023 |
| url |
https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/RSD/article/view/38884 |
| work_keys_str_mv |
AT cabreramendozanestorivan contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT diazdeleoncastanedachristian contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT velezalvarezconsuelo contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT pavonleonpatricia contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT gogeascoecheatrejomariadelcarmen contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT gutierrezalbagaudencio contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT camposuscangayolanda contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT ortizleonmariacristina contentvalidityofthequestionnairetechnologyacceptanceinhealthsystemsaceptessintwolatinamericancountries AT cabreramendozanestorivan validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT diazdeleoncastanedachristian validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT velezalvarezconsuelo validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT pavonleonpatricia validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT gogeascoecheatrejomariadelcarmen validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT gutierrezalbagaudencio validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT camposuscangayolanda validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT ortizleonmariacristina validezdecontenidodelcuestionariodeaceptaciontecnologicaensistemasdesaludendospaiseslatinoamericanos AT cabreramendozanestorivan validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT diazdeleoncastanedachristian validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT velezalvarezconsuelo validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT pavonleonpatricia validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT gogeascoecheatrejomariadelcarmen validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT gutierrezalbagaudencio validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT camposuscangayolanda validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos AT ortizleonmariacristina validadedoconteudodoquestionariodeaceitacaotecnologicaemsistemasdesaudeacceptessemdoispaiseslatinoamericanos |
| first_indexed |
2024-09-03T22:27:17Z |
| last_indexed |
2025-05-10T05:22:31Z |
| _version_ |
1841584880620666880 |
| spelling |
I10-R360-article-388842025-04-03T12:05:18Z Content validity of the questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) in two latin american countries Validez de contenido del cuestionario de Aceptación Tecnológica en Sistemas de Salud en dos países latinoamericanos Validade do conteúdo do questionário de Aceitação Tecnológica em Sistemas de Saúde (ACCEPTESS) em dois países latino-americanos Cabrera Mendoza, Néstor Iván Díaz de León Castañeda, Christian Vélez Álvarez, Consuelo Pavón León, Patricia Gogeascoechea Trejo, María del Carmen Gutiérrez Alba, Gaudencio Campos Uscanga, Yolanda Ortiz León, María Cristina Validation Study Case Management Health Systems Delphi Technique Information Technology Estudio de validación Manejo de caso Sistemas de salud Técnica Delfos Tecnología de la información Introduction: Some studies conducted in Latin America have evaluated the access and use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) by healthcare personnel in health services. However, the instruments that were used focused on specific technologies and had limited evidence regarding validity and reliability. Objective: To develop a questionnaire to assess the availability, acceptance, and use of ICT as mechanisms for care coordination and the factors influencing public health services, and to analyze its content validity. Materials and Methods: The questionnaire ‘Technology Acceptance in Health Systems’ (ACEPTESS) was designed and adapted for Mexico and Colombia. Content validity was analyzed using Delphi method in three phases: 1) preparatory phase, 2) consultation phase, and 3) consensus phase. Nineteen judges, experts in Health Technologies and Health Systems Management participated (8 in Mexico and 11 in Colombia). A digital validation format was used to evaluate the questionnaire items based on four categories: sufficiency, clarity, coherence, and relevance. Consultation phase included two rounds; and degree of agreement among experts was determined using the content validity coefficient. Results: The ACEPTESS questionnaire obtained an overall "excellent" level of agreement in both countries (Mexico: 0.9541; Colombia: 0.9644). The final version of the ACEPTESS questionnaire included 65 items divided into four sections. Conclusions: The results suggest that the ACEPTESS questionnaire has evidence of content validity for assessing ICT as mechanisms for care coordination and the factors influencing public health services in Mexico and Colombia. Keywords: Validation study, Case management, Health systems, Delphi Technique, IT Introducción: Algunos estudios realizados en Latinoamérica han evaluado el acceso y uso de Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicación (TIC) por parte de personal sanitario en servicios de salud, sin embargo, los instrumentos utilizados se orientaron en tecnologías particulares y contaron con limitada evidencia de validez y confiabilidad. Objetivo: Desarrollar un cuestionario para evaluar la disponibilidad, aceptación y uso de TIC como mecanismos de coordinación asistencial y los factores que influyen en servicios públicos de salud y analizar su validez de contenido. Material y métodos: Se diseñó el cuestionario de Aceptación Tecnológica en Sistemas de Salud (ACEPTESS), siendo adaptado para México y Colombia. Se analizó la validez de contenido mediante el método Delphi bajo tres fases: 1) fase preparatoria, 2) fase de consulta y, 3) fase de consenso. Participaron 19 jueces expertos/as en Tecnologías en Salud y Gerencia de Sistemas de Salud (8 en México y 11 en Colombia). Se utilizó un formato de validación digital para evaluar los ítems del cuestionario bajo cuatro categorías: suficiencia, claridad, coherencia y relevancia. La fase de consulta contempló dos rondas. Se determinó el grado de concordancia entre expertos según el coeficiente de validez de contenido. Resultados: El cuestionario ACEPTESS obtuvo un índice global de concordancia ‘excelente’ en ambos países (México: 0.9541; Colombia: 0.9644). La versión final del cuestionario ACEPTESS incluyó 65 ítems divididos en cuatro secciones. Conclusiones: Los resultados sugieren que el cuestionario ACEPTESS cuenta con evidencia de validez de contenido para evaluar TIC como mecanismos de coordinación asistencial y los factores que influyen en servicios públicos de salud de México y Colombia. Palabras clave: estudio de validación, manejo de caso, sistemas de salud, técnica Delfos, tecnología de la información Introdução: Algumas pesquisas realizadas na América Latina avaliaram o acesso e uso das Tecnologias de Informação e Comunicação (TIC) por profissionais de saúde nos serviços sanitários, porém, os instrumentos utilizados estiveram focados em tecnologias particulares e apresentaram evidências limitadas de validade e confiabilidade. Objetivo: Desenvolver um questionário para avaliar a disponibilidade, aceitação e uso das TIC como mecanismos de coordenação assistencial e os fatores que influenciam os serviços públicos de saúde e analisar a sua validade de conteúdo. Material e métodos: Desenhou-se o questionário de Aceitação Tecnológica em Sistemas de Saúde (ACEPTESS), sendo adaptado para o México e a Colômbia. A validade de conteúdo foi analisada pelo método Delphi em três fases: 1) fase preparatória, 2) fase de consulta e 3) fase de consenso. Participaram 19 juízes especialistas em Tecnologias de Saúde e Gestão de Sistemas de Saúde (8 no México e 11 na Colômbia). Utilizou-se um formato de validação digital para avaliar os itens do questionário em quatro categorias: suficiência, clareza, coerência e relevância. A fase de consulta incluiu duas rodadas. O grau de concordância entre os juízes foi determinado de acordo com o coeficiente de validade de conteúdo. Resultados: O questionário ACEPTESS obteve um índice geral de concordância 'excelente' em ambos os países (México: 0,9541; Colômbia: 0,9644). A versão final do questionário ACEPTESS incluiu 65 itens divididos em quatro seções. Conclusões: Os resultados sugerem que o questionário ACEPTESS possui evidências de validade de conteúdo para avaliar as TIC como mecanismos de coordenação assistencial e os fatores que influenciam os serviços públicos de saúde no México e na Colômbia. Palavras-chave: Estudo de validação, Gestão de casos, Sistemas de saúde, Técnica Delfos, Tecnologia da informação Escuela de Salud Pública y Ambiente. Fac. Cs. Médicas UNC 2023-06-30 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf text/html https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/RSD/article/view/38884 10.31052/1853.1180.v29.n1.38884 Revista de Salud Pública; Vol. 29 Núm. 1 (2023): Revista de Salud Pública 1852-9429 1853-1180 10.31052/1853.1180.v29.n1 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/RSD/article/view/38884/41707 https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/RSD/article/view/38884/41719 Derechos de autor 2023 Universidad Nacional de Córdoba https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0 |