THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY

The problem of political obligation, i.e., the kind of bond that exists between citizens and the political community of which they are members, encompasses a good number of sub-themes of enormous complexity. One of them is the question of whether people who do not benefit from a pr...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Magoja, Eduardo Esteban
Formato: Artículo revista
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: Facultad de Derecho 2023
Materias:
Political obligation
Injustice
Law
Multiple principle theory
Obligación política
Injusticia
Derecho
Teoría de múltiples principios
Acceso en línea:https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/refade/article/view/43656
Aporte de:
Revista de la Facultad de Derecho de Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
id I10-R353-article-43656
record_format ojs
spelling I10-R353-article-436562024-03-08T15:09:24Z THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY EL PROBLEMA DE LA OBLIGACIÓN POLÍTICA EN SITUACIONES DE INJUSTICIAS ECONÓMICAS Y SOCIALES: UNA RESPUESTA DESDE UNA TEORÍA DE MÚLTIPLES PRINCIPIOS Magoja, Eduardo Esteban Political obligation Injustice Law Multiple principle theory Obligación política Injusticia Derecho Teoría de múltiples principios The problem of political obligation, i.e., the kind of bond that exists between citizens and the political community of which they are members, encompasses a good number of sub-themes of enormous complexity. One of them is the question of whether people who do not benefit from a proper distribution of goods and burdens are under a duty to submit to the authority of law. Much has been written about the requirements that distribution must satisfy to be just and produce obedience, but scholars do not usually analyze the possibility that law can keep its normative force in cases of (non-extreme) injustice. In this paper, I assume the challenge of addressing this complex topic, which is of special interest in the context of Latin American democratic states. By a combination ofthe theory of fair play, the duty to support just institutions and a principle of the common good (a multiple principle theory) I will seek to defend the thesis that even in a just or nearly just society, where the distribution of goods and burdens could be deficient, citizens prima facie have to obey the law. El problema de la obligación política, esto es, el tipo de vínculo que existe entre los ciudadanos y la comunidad política en la que ellos son miembros, engloba una buena cantidad de subtemas de enorme complejidad. Uno de estos es la cuestión acerca de si las personas que no gozan de un reparto apropiado de bienes y cargas tienen el deber de someterse a la autoridad del derecho. Muchose ha escrito sobre los requisitos que debe satisfacer la distribución para ser justa y generar obediencia; pero no se suele examinar la posibilidad de que el derecho sea capaz de conservar su fuerza normativa en casos de injusticia (no extrema). En este trabajo se asume el desafío de abordar aquel punto complejo, el cual es de especial interés en el contexto de los Estados democráticos latinoamericanos. Mediante una combinación de la teoría del fair play, el deber de apoyar las instituciones justas y un principio de bien común (una teoría de múltiples principios) se buscará defender la tesis de que incluso en esquemas justos o casi justos, dondela distribución de bienes y cargas puede resultar un tanto deficitaria, prima facie los ciudadanos tienen un deber de obediencia hacia el derecho. Facultad de Derecho 2023-12-14 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/refade/article/view/43656 10.31054/2314.3061.v14.n2.43656 Revista de la Facultad de Derecho; Vol. 14 Núm. 2 (2023): NUEVA SERIE II; 49-74 2314-3061 1850-9371 10.31054/2314.3061.v14.n2 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/refade/article/view/43656/43717 Derechos de autor 2023 Facultad de Derecho. Universidad Nacional de Córdoba http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
institution Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
institution_str I-10
repository_str R-353
container_title_str Revista de la Facultad de Derecho
language Español
format Artículo revista
topic Political obligation
Injustice
Law
Multiple principle theory
Obligación política
Injusticia
Derecho
Teoría de múltiples principios
spellingShingle Political obligation
Injustice
Law
Multiple principle theory
Obligación política
Injusticia
Derecho
Teoría de múltiples principios
Magoja, Eduardo Esteban
THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
topic_facet Political obligation
Injustice
Law
Multiple principle theory
Obligación política
Injusticia
Derecho
Teoría de múltiples principios
author Magoja, Eduardo Esteban
author_facet Magoja, Eduardo Esteban
author_sort Magoja, Eduardo Esteban
title THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
title_short THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
title_full THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
title_fullStr THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
title_full_unstemmed THE PROBLEM OF POLITICAL OBLIGATION IN SITUATIONS OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL INJUSTICES: A RESPONSE FROM A MULTIPLE PRINCIPLE THEORY
title_sort problem of political obligation in situations of economic and social injustices: a response from a multiple principle theory
description The problem of political obligation, i.e., the kind of bond that exists between citizens and the political community of which they are members, encompasses a good number of sub-themes of enormous complexity. One of them is the question of whether people who do not benefit from a proper distribution of goods and burdens are under a duty to submit to the authority of law. Much has been written about the requirements that distribution must satisfy to be just and produce obedience, but scholars do not usually analyze the possibility that law can keep its normative force in cases of (non-extreme) injustice. In this paper, I assume the challenge of addressing this complex topic, which is of special interest in the context of Latin American democratic states. By a combination ofthe theory of fair play, the duty to support just institutions and a principle of the common good (a multiple principle theory) I will seek to defend the thesis that even in a just or nearly just society, where the distribution of goods and burdens could be deficient, citizens prima facie have to obey the law.
publisher Facultad de Derecho
publishDate 2023
url https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/refade/article/view/43656
work_keys_str_mv AT magojaeduardoesteban theproblemofpoliticalobligationinsituationsofeconomicandsocialinjusticesaresponsefromamultipleprincipletheory
AT magojaeduardoesteban elproblemadelaobligacionpoliticaensituacionesdeinjusticiaseconomicasysocialesunarespuestadesdeunateoriademultiplesprincipios
AT magojaeduardoesteban problemofpoliticalobligationinsituationsofeconomicandsocialinjusticesaresponsefromamultipleprincipletheory
first_indexed 2024-09-03T22:19:12Z
last_indexed 2024-09-03T22:19:12Z
_version_ 1809215077807554560

Ejemplares similares