The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case
This paper analyzes the use of the rule of clear mistake on criminal decisions taken by Cordoba´s Superior Court of Justice. This rule states that an act can only be disregard when those who have the right to make laws have not merely made a mistake, but have made a very clear one, so clear that it...
Guardado en:
| Autores principales: | , |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Artículo revista |
| Lenguaje: | Español |
| Publicado: |
Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET
2022
|
| Materias: | |
| Acceso en línea: | https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37563 |
| Aporte de: |
| id |
I10-R282-article-37563 |
|---|---|
| record_format |
ojs |
| spelling |
I10-R282-article-375632022-05-17T20:00:57Z The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case ¿"Clara equivocación del legislador"? Un análisis a partir del caso "Loyola" Álvarez, Magdalena Inés Ferniot, Cecilia Control de constitucionalidad Clara equivocación del legislador Autorrestricción del poder judicial Deferencia legislativa Laguna axiológica Analogía in bonam partem Constitutionality check Rule of clear mistake Judicial restraint Deference to decisions made by political branches Axiological gap Bonam partem analogy This paper analyzes the use of the rule of clear mistake on criminal decisions taken by Cordoba´s Superior Court of Justice. This rule states that an act can only be disregard when those who have the right to make laws have not merely made a mistake, but have made a very clear one, so clear that it is not open to rational question. The local court takes the rule from a work published by Thayer in 1893. In this lines, we attend to show that the use of the rule made in case «Loyola» is opposite to Thayer’s proposal. El trabajo aborda el uso del argumento “clara equivocación del legislador” como recurso para declarar la inconstitucionalidad de normas penales de fondo. Este argumento, utilizado por el TSJ al resolver el caso «Loyola», afirma que una ley solo puede ser anulada cuando el legislador ha cometido, no una mera equivocación, sino un error tan claro que no queda abierto a una cuestión racional. El tribunal toma el estándar de un trabajo publicado por Thayer en 1893. Mas, como se demuestra en este trabajo, el uso que hace del argumento en el caso «Loyola» no se corresponde -incluso, se contrapone- con la doctrina desarrollada en dicha publicación. Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET 2022-05-17 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37563 Anuario del Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales; Núm. XX (2022): ANUARIO; 25-44 1667-6122 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37563/37632 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0 |
| institution |
Universidad Nacional de Córdoba |
| institution_str |
I-10 |
| repository_str |
R-282 |
| container_title_str |
Anuario del Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales |
| language |
Español |
| format |
Artículo revista |
| topic |
Control de constitucionalidad Clara equivocación del legislador Autorrestricción del poder judicial Deferencia legislativa Laguna axiológica Analogía in bonam partem Constitutionality check Rule of clear mistake Judicial restraint Deference to decisions made by political branches Axiological gap Bonam partem analogy |
| spellingShingle |
Control de constitucionalidad Clara equivocación del legislador Autorrestricción del poder judicial Deferencia legislativa Laguna axiológica Analogía in bonam partem Constitutionality check Rule of clear mistake Judicial restraint Deference to decisions made by political branches Axiological gap Bonam partem analogy Álvarez, Magdalena Inés Ferniot, Cecilia The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| topic_facet |
Control de constitucionalidad Clara equivocación del legislador Autorrestricción del poder judicial Deferencia legislativa Laguna axiológica Analogía in bonam partem Constitutionality check Rule of clear mistake Judicial restraint Deference to decisions made by political branches Axiological gap Bonam partem analogy |
| author |
Álvarez, Magdalena Inés Ferniot, Cecilia |
| author_facet |
Álvarez, Magdalena Inés Ferniot, Cecilia |
| author_sort |
Álvarez, Magdalena Inés |
| title |
The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| title_short |
The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| title_full |
The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| title_fullStr |
The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| title_full_unstemmed |
The rule of clear mistake. An analisys from "Loyola" case |
| title_sort |
rule of clear mistake. an analisys from "loyola" case |
| description |
This paper analyzes the use of the rule of clear mistake on criminal decisions taken by Cordoba´s Superior Court of Justice. This rule states that an act can only be disregard when those who have the right to make laws have not merely made a mistake, but have made a very clear one, so clear that it is not open to rational question. The local court takes the rule from a work published by Thayer in 1893. In this lines, we attend to show that the use of the rule made in case «Loyola» is opposite to Thayer’s proposal. |
| publisher |
Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET |
| publishDate |
2022 |
| url |
https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37563 |
| work_keys_str_mv |
AT alvarezmagdalenaines theruleofclearmistakeananalisysfromloyolacase AT ferniotcecilia theruleofclearmistakeananalisysfromloyolacase AT alvarezmagdalenaines claraequivocaciondellegisladorunanalisisapartirdelcasoloyola AT ferniotcecilia claraequivocaciondellegisladorunanalisisapartirdelcasoloyola AT alvarezmagdalenaines ruleofclearmistakeananalisysfromloyolacase AT ferniotcecilia ruleofclearmistakeananalisysfromloyolacase |
| first_indexed |
2024-09-03T22:38:42Z |
| last_indexed |
2024-09-03T22:38:42Z |
| _version_ |
1809216304346824704 |