Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030

This paper analyzes the participation of national Indigenous peoples' organizations in an environmental-climate public policy: Argentina’s National Adaptation Plan 2030 (2019–2022). The study is based on ethnographic fieldwork, semi-structured interviews, document analysis, and theoretical appr...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar
Formato: Artículo revista
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: Escuela de Antropología - FHyA 2025
Materias:
cambio climático
ambiente
participación
pueblos originarios
territorio
climate change
environment
participation
indigenous peoples
territories
mudanças climáticas
participação
povos indígenas
territórios
Acceso en línea:https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322
Aporte de:
Revista de la Escuela de Antropología de Universidad Nacional de Rosario
id I15-R207-article-322
record_format ojs
institution Universidad Nacional de Rosario
institution_str I-15
repository_str R-207
container_title_str Revista de la Escuela de Antropología
language Español
format Artículo revista
topic cambio climático
ambiente
participación
pueblos originarios
territorio
climate change
environment
participation
indigenous peoples
territories
mudanças climáticas
ambiente
participação
povos indígenas
territórios
spellingShingle cambio climático
ambiente
participación
pueblos originarios
territorio
climate change
environment
participation
indigenous peoples
territories
mudanças climáticas
ambiente
participação
povos indígenas
territórios
Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar
Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
topic_facet cambio climático
ambiente
participación
pueblos originarios
territorio
climate change
environment
participation
indigenous peoples
territories
mudanças climáticas
ambiente
participação
povos indígenas
territórios
author Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar
author_facet Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar
author_sort Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar
title Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
title_short Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
title_full Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
title_fullStr Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
title_full_unstemmed Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030
title_sort environmental-climate policies and indigenous participation in argentina: the case of the national climate change adaptation plan 2030
description This paper analyzes the participation of national Indigenous peoples' organizations in an environmental-climate public policy: Argentina’s National Adaptation Plan 2030 (2019–2022). The study is based on ethnographic fieldwork, semi-structured interviews, document analysis, and theoretical approaches from political ecology and biopolitics. The analysis highlights, on one hand, Indigenous agency through formal-institutional and organizational arrangements aimed at ensuring participation in the Plan; and on the other, the persistence of structural state debts: a disconnect between discourses of recognition of diversity, institutional capacity, and a productive extractivist model based on the commodification of life and the environment. Furthermore, the research identifies alternatives introduced into the public-political debate—concepts and knowledge that emphasize communal life and underpin powerful proposals for alternative models of environmental and territorial development, such as Development with Identity, Buen Vivir, and Territory.
publisher Escuela de Antropología - FHyA
publishDate 2025
url https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322
work_keys_str_mv AT manzanellimacarenadelpilar environmentalclimatepoliciesandindigenousparticipationinargentinathecaseofthenationalclimatechangeadaptationplan2030
AT manzanellimacarenadelpilar politicasambientalesclimaticasyparticipacionindigenaenargentinaelcasodelplannacionaldeadaptacionalcambioclimatico2030
AT manzanellimacarenadelpilar politicasambientaisclimaticaseparticipacaoindigenanaargentinaocasodoprojetonacionaldeadaptacaoasalteracoesclimaticas2030
first_indexed 2025-09-04T05:05:14Z
last_indexed 2025-09-04T05:05:14Z
_version_ 1842308515440361472
spelling I15-R207-article-3222025-07-22T14:56:27Z Environmental-Climate Policies and Indigenous Participation in Argentina: The Case of the National Climate Change Adaptation Plan 2030 Políticas ambientales-climáticas y participación indígena en Argentina. El caso del Plan Nacional de Adaptación al Cambio Climático 2030 Políticas ambientais climáticas e participação indígena na Argentina. O caso do Projeto Nacional de Adaptação às Alterações Climáticas 2030 Manzanelli, Macarena Del Pilar cambio climático ambiente participación pueblos originarios territorio climate change environment participation indigenous peoples territories mudanças climáticas ambiente participação povos indígenas territórios This paper analyzes the participation of national Indigenous peoples' organizations in an environmental-climate public policy: Argentina’s National Adaptation Plan 2030 (2019–2022). The study is based on ethnographic fieldwork, semi-structured interviews, document analysis, and theoretical approaches from political ecology and biopolitics. The analysis highlights, on one hand, Indigenous agency through formal-institutional and organizational arrangements aimed at ensuring participation in the Plan; and on the other, the persistence of structural state debts: a disconnect between discourses of recognition of diversity, institutional capacity, and a productive extractivist model based on the commodification of life and the environment. Furthermore, the research identifies alternatives introduced into the public-political debate—concepts and knowledge that emphasize communal life and underpin powerful proposals for alternative models of environmental and territorial development, such as Development with Identity, Buen Vivir, and Territory. Este trabajo analiza instancias de participación de organizaciones nacionales de pueblos originarios en una política pública ambiental-climática, el Plan Nacional de Adaptación 2030 en Argentina (2019-2022). Se partió de un trabajo etnográfico, junto con entrevistas semiestructuradas, análisis documental y enfoques teóricos de ecología política y biopolítica. El análisis reflejó, por un lado, la agencia indígena con arreglos formales-institucionales y organizativos para garantizar la participación en dicho Plan; por otro, la persistencia de deudas estructurales estatales: desfasaje entre retóricas de reconocimiento a la diversidad, capacidad institucional y un perfil productivo extractivista de comodificación de la vida y del ambiente. Asimismo, se identificaron alternativas al introducir al debate público-político nociones y saberes que enfatizan en la vida comunitaria y sustentan propuestas potentes de otros modos de desarrollo ambiental-territorial: Desarrollo con identidad, Buen Vivir y Territorio.  Este artigo analisa casos de participação de organizações nacionais de povos indígenas em uma política pública ambiental e climática, o Plano Nacional de Adaptação 2030 na Argentina (2019-2022). O trabalho foi baseado em trabalho etnográfico, entrevistas semiestruturadas, análise documental e abordagens teóricas sobre ecologia política e biopolítica. A análise da participação indígena refletiu, por um lado, a agência indígena com arranjos institucionais e organizacionais formais para garantir a participação indígena no referido Plano; Por outro lado, a persistência de dívidas estruturais estatais: um distanciamento entre a retórica de reconhecimento da diversidade, a capacidade institucional e um perfil de produção extrativista de mercantilização da vida e do meio ambiente; e alternativas, introduzindo no debate público-político noções e conhecimentos que enfatizem a vida comunitária e sustentem propostas potentes para outros modos de desenvolvimento ambiental-territorial - Desenvolvimento com Identidade, Bem Viver e Território-. Escuela de Antropología - FHyA 2025-07-21 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf text/html application/epub+zip https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322 10.35305/rea.XXXVI.322 Revista de la Escuela de Antropología; Núm. XXXVI (2025) 2618-2998 1852-1576 spa https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322/374 https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322/375 https://revistadeantropologia.unr.edu.ar/index.php/revistadeantropologia/article/view/322/376 Derechos de autor 2025 Macarena Del Pilar Manzanelli https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

Ejemplares similares